Top 6 Best Hamilton Beach Brewmaster 2020: Reviews and Buying Guide

"I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Read more"

When it comes to home appliances, there aren’t too many brands out there that can beat Hamilton Beach, and there coffee makers may just be some of the best ones out there.

However, there are just so many different models and series that come from the brand that making the choice can sometimes feel impossible. That’s why I’ve compiled a list of reviews of some of the best coffee makers from Hamilton Beach.

In this article, you’ll find Hamilton Beach Brewmaster reviews, along with a couple of Hamilton Beach FlexBrew reviews, as these are some of their premiere models.

My personal choice for the best one though has to be the Hamilton Beach Flexbrew 49957 2-way coffee makers as it can give me a wide range of coffee options, as well as being convenient to use. But if you don’t think this is the one for you, don’t worry, as you’ll probably find it in this list if you keep reading.

See also:

  1. Top 8 Best Bunn Coffee Makers Reviews 2020 – Most Durable & Reliable Picks
  2. Top 6 Best Ground Coffee 2020: Reviews & Buying Guide\
  3. Top 6 Best Commercial Espresso Machines 2020: Comparisons, Reviews and Buyer’s Guide

Best Hamilton Beach Brewmaster: Quick Summary

Best Multiple Use Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach Flexbrew Thermal Coffee Maker
Best For Serving Large Crowds
Hamilton Beach 40515 45-Cup Coffee Urn
Best Programmable Brewstation
Hamilton Beach Brewstation 47950 12-Cup Coffee Maker
Best Overall Pick
Hamilton Beach Flexbrew 49957 2-Way Coffee Maker
Best Single Serve Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew 49974
Best FlexBrew 49957 Alternative
Hamilton Beach 2-Way Brewer 49980A Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Thermal Coffee Maker, Single Serve & Full Pot, Compatible with K-Cup Pods or Grounds, Programmable, Black and Stainless (49966)
Hamilton Beach 45 Cup Coffee Urn and Hot Beverage Dispenser, Silver
Hamilton Beach (47950) Coffee Maker with 12 Cup Capacity & Internal Storage Coffee Pot, Brewstation, Black/Stainless Steel
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew 49957 2-Way Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Single Serve Coffee Maker, Compatible with K-Cup Pods and Grounds, Black (49974)
Hamilton Beach 2-Way Brewer Coffee Maker, Single-Serve and 12-Cup Pot, Stainless Steel (49980A), Carafe
$109.99
$42.99
$59.00
$102.99
$39.85
$79.00
-
Best Multiple Use Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach Flexbrew Thermal Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Thermal Coffee Maker, Single Serve & Full Pot, Compatible with K-Cup Pods or Grounds, Programmable, Black and Stainless (49966)
$109.99
Best For Serving Large Crowds
Hamilton Beach 40515 45-Cup Coffee Urn
Hamilton Beach 45 Cup Coffee Urn and Hot Beverage Dispenser, Silver
$42.99
Best Programmable Brewstation
Hamilton Beach Brewstation 47950 12-Cup Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach (47950) Coffee Maker with 12 Cup Capacity & Internal Storage Coffee Pot, Brewstation, Black/Stainless Steel
$59.00
Best Overall Pick
Hamilton Beach Flexbrew 49957 2-Way Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew 49957 2-Way Coffee Maker
$102.99
-
Best Single Serve Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew 49974
Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Single Serve Coffee Maker, Compatible with K-Cup Pods and Grounds, Black (49974)
$39.85
Best FlexBrew 49957 Alternative
Hamilton Beach 2-Way Brewer 49980A Coffee Maker
Hamilton Beach 2-Way Brewer Coffee Maker, Single-Serve and 12-Cup Pot, Stainless Steel (49980A), Carafe
$79.00

Top 6 Best Hamilton Beach Brewmaster

#1, Hamilton Beach Flexbrew Thermal Coffee Maker – The Best Multiple Use Coffee Maker

Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Thermal Coffee Maker, Single Serve & Full Pot, Compatible with K-Cup Pods or Grounds, Programmable, Black and Stainless (49966)
  • Two ways to brew: Brew a full pot using your favorite grounds on the thermal carafe side or make a cup for yourself using a Keurig k-cup pod or grounds on the single-serve side with this 2-in-1 coffee maker
  • Stainless steel, 10-cup thermal carafe: Thermal carafe keeps coffee hot and fresh. Features programmable timer, auto pause & serve and auto shutoff
  • Single-serve-brew with K-Cup pods or without: Pod holder and single-serve grounds basket are included. Features cup rest that adjusts to fit tall mugs and doubles as storage. Pod-piercing needle removes for easy cleaning to prevent clogging
  • Separate water reservoirs: Each brewer has its own water reservoir that’s easy to fill and features a water window so you always know which brewer has how much water
  • Brewing flexibility: The Hamilton Beach flex brew 2-way coffee maker has the option to please fans of all types of coffees and quantities, making it the perfect gift for a home with multiple coffee drinkers

Kicking things off is a great coffee maker for those who have multiple coffee drinkers in the house. No two people would like their coffee exactly the same, which is why there are two ways for you to brew your coffee on this machine.

On the left side, you have a thermal carafe that can be used to make multiple cups of coffee. An ideal option for those who need to make larger batches. But if you only need one cup, you can go to the left side where it has a single serve coffee maker.

You can use both pods and regular coffee grinds on that side to help you produce a brew that is fine-tuned to your taste. It should be worth mentioning, however, that this isn’t the most durable coffee maker and some customers have complained about issues arising from the single-serve side after some use.

Brew time for the single serve side is around three minutes, which is a very short time to wait for a strong, well rounded, and flavorful cup of coffee. The machine also has two separate reservoirs for each brewer, and they also have water windows that will allow you to see how much water you have left.

This machine also is programmable so it can automatically brew your coffee for you based on your schedule, and it also gives you two brewing options, which is great if the people in your household have different tastes and preferences when it comes to their cup of joe.

Pros
  • Comes with two brewers
  • Has two separate water reservoirs
  • Easy to use
  • Programmable brewing time
  • Comes with two brewing options
Cons
  • May not be the most durable model

#2, Hamilton Beach 40515 45-Cup Coffee Urn – The Best For Serving Large Crowds

Sale
Hamilton Beach 45 Cup Coffee Urn and Hot Beverage Dispenser, Silver
  • Fast brewing, takes just 1 minute to brew each cup
  • Brews enough for a crowd: makes 15 to 45 cups of hot, fresh Coffee, perfect for social gatherings and buffet style meals
  • 2 Way dispenser for single cup or continuous filling
  • Easy to fill: water level markings in the urn’s interior make measuring water a snap
  • Ready to serve indicator light

If you find yourself hosting events or needing to make large batches of coffee for a lot of people often, this may be the best pick for you. As the name suggests, it can brew and store up to 45 cups of coffee, which is great for meetings, forums, and other types of events.

This is a very useful coffee machine, as it can brew a cup of coffee in about a minute’s time, and it also has an indicating light to let you know when your coffee is ready. And if your event isn’t that big, you can brew batches as small as 15 cups, which gives you a bit more flexibility.

This machine is also very easy to use, all you have to do is fill the reservoir up with water, put your coffee beans in, turn the machine on and wait. It also has handles placed in very smart positions around the coffee maker to allow you to carry it around very easily.

One of the only downsides to this model is the fact that it doesn’t have a cup trip handle to make dispensing easier. But aside from that, this may be the best coffee maker for large crowds that you can get your hands on.

Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Can make up to 45 cups
  • Fast brewing time
  • Easy to move around
  • Has an indicator light
Cons
  • Doesn’t have a cup trip handle

#3, Hamilton Beach Brewstation 47950 12-Cup Coffee Maker – The Best Programmable Brewstation

Hamilton Beach (47950) Coffee Maker with 12 Cup Capacity & Internal Storage Coffee Pot, Brewstation, Black/Stainless Steel
  • The original 12 cup dispensing coffeemaker
  • Forget the Carafe - 12 cup dispensing coffeemaker without a carafe
  • Removable water reservoir makes filling easy
  • Brews a full 12 cups and dispenses one fresh cup at a time
  • No carafe means no pouring, no spilling, no breaking and no burnt coffee flavor

The Brewstation line of Hamilton Beach is arguably their most popular one, and coffee makers like this model are a prime example why.

This machine is programmable, so you can set it up before you sleep, and when you wake up in the morning, your coffee will be ready for you. It also has multiple brewing options, so if you want your coffee stronger and with a fuller flavor, you can simply select the “bold” option. On top of that, you can also make a cold brew by selecting the “Iced Coffee” setting.

Aside from being programmable, it also has no carafe. Yup, you read that right. This coffee maker can store up to 12 cups of coffee without a carafe. This is done using an internal reservoir that can keep your coffee warm and retain its fresh taste, and ready to be dispensed whenever you’d like.

This machine can keep your coffee hot for up to four hours, which is great for those who need to go through multiple cups of coffee in the morning. So if you need a lot of coffee to get you going, or if you’re brewing for the whole household, this model might be your best bet.

Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Programmable
  • Stores up to 12 cups of coffee without a carafe
  • Multiple brewing options
  • Can keep coffee hot for up to four hours
Cons
  • Cleaning the machine can get pretty tricky

#4, Hamilton Beach Flexbrew 49957 2-Way Coffee Maker – The Best Overall Pick

Hamilton Beach FlexBrew 49957 2-Way Coffee Maker
  • Two easy-fill reservoirs and easy-view water windows
  • Carafe side with programmable timer
  • 2-hour auto shutoff
  • Bold or Regular brew strength options
  • Automatic Pause & Serve function when removing carafe

Next up on the list is my personal favorite model, as it can brew multiple cups in a carafe and it can also brew single-cup servings using pods or coffee grinds.

K-cups are a great way of getting a flavorful and strong cup of coffee in the morning, and this machine can handle it really well. It only takes 2-3 minutes to brew a cup using the single-serve side, and it will take around 7-10 minutes to fill up the carafe. This isn’t a lot of time at all, and it’s well-worth the wait for a quality cup of joe in the morning.

This is a programmable machine, so if you want to schedule when your coffee gets brewed, you can do it with ease. Another great feature of this machine is that it’s very durable, so it can brew you great coffee for years to come.

It’s a great pick for those who live with families as it can brew single cups and full carafes with ease.

Pros
  • Durable
  • Two-way brewing
  • Quick brewing time
  • Has bold and regular brewing options
  • Automatic pause function when you remove the carafe
Cons
  • Relatively expensive

#5, Hamilton Beach FlexBrew 49974 – The Best Single Serve Coffee Maker

Hamilton Beach FlexBrew Single Serve Coffee Maker, Compatible with K-Cup Pods and Grounds, Black (49974)
  • Single-serve coffee maker with or without K-Cup pods. Brew up to 10 ounce. With a K-Cup pod, or up to a 14 ounce. travel mug with grounds. Pod holder and grounds basket are included.
  • Just lower lid and brew: Whether it’s a single-serve pod or your own fresh grounds, just place them in the holder, lower the lid and press brew. The coffee maker automatically shuts off when brewing is complete.
  • Personal coffee maker: The flex brew single-serve coffee maker is the perfect gift for college students, small kitchens, the office or anyone who prefers to have a fresh cup of coffee each time they brew.
  • Fits a variety of mugs: Use the adjustable cup rest to not only fit your favorite mug in just right, but to also store the single-serve pod holder or the brew basket.
  • Easy to clean: The pod-piercing needle removes for easy cleaning to prevent clogging that can sometimes occur with frequent use.

If you only plan on brewing for one or two people, chances are you won’t need the large carafes that come with some of the other models on this list. And if you’ve been looking for one of the top single serve coffee makers on the market today, this might just be it.

This coffee maker can work with K-pods and simple coffee grinds, which automatically gives you a fair amount of options when it comes to your morning cup of joe. It’s also very easy to use, all you have to do is load water in the reservoir, put the pod or coffee beans in the holder, then wait. It takes around 3 minutes to brew a nice cup of coffee in this maker, which isn’t a lot of time at all.

The cup rest for this maker is adjustable, which means you can put anyone of your favorite mugs in it without worrying about the fit. This is also an environmentally friendly coffee maker as it will only heat up the water when you’re brewing coffee, as opposed to other makers that constantly keep the water hot, which tends to waste power.

Another plus with this maker is that you can use your favorite large travel mug with it. Maintenance with this maker is also very easy as it doesn’t take much effort to remove the pod piercing needle to clean it.

This is a great personal coffee maker, and arguably one of the best single-serve coffee makers on the market today.

Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Easy to clean
  • Makes great coffee
  • Quick brewing time
  • Compatible with pods and regular coffee beans
Cons
  • Only makes one cup at a time

#6, Hamilton Beach 2-Way Brewer 49980A Coffee Maker – The Best FlexBrew 49957 Alternative

Sale
Hamilton Beach 2-Way Brewer Coffee Maker, Single-Serve and 12-Cup Pot, Stainless Steel (49980A), Carafe
  • Brew two ways: Enjoy either a single-serve cup (travel mug not included) or full pot of coffee with the 12-cup carafe.
  • Fully programmable: Wake up to a hot cup of coffee with fully programmable functionality and auto-shutoff.
  • Adjusts to your cup: Can brew directly into the carafe, a travel mug (not included) or a short cup (not included)
  • Convenient single-serve: Brew a cup for one using loose, ground coffee.
  • Smart features: Includes brew strength selector (regular or bold), keep-hot warming plate and more.

While the best overall pick on this list was also a two way brewer, this specific Hamilton Beach model stands out as one of the best two-way coffee brewers on the market today.

It’s a relatively affordable model, and it can brew coffee in a carafe when you need a lot of coffee, and in a single cup when you’re only making some for yourself. It’s a programmable coffee maker, so you can set it up before you sleep and you can wake up to a great cup of coffee every morning.

The carafe that comes with this model can hold up to 12 cups of coffee, which could come in handy when you’re making coffee for guests or for family breakfast in the morning. It also has two different brew options (bold and regular) to give you variety when it comes to the flavors in your coffee.

This machine is very easy to use, which is why it’s popular amongst coffee drinkers all over. However, customers have noted that the brewing time of this maker is pretty long, taking up to 10 minutes sometimes, which could be a hassle for those who don’t have the luxury of time in the morning. But if you’re willing to wait and aren’t up to getting the FlexBrew 49957, then this is a very-worthy alternative.

Pros
  • Works with pods and ground coffee beans
  • Easy to use
  • Brews single-serve and 12-cup carafes
  • Has a warming plate
  • Programmable
Cons
  • Brewing time can be slow

What To Look For When Buying A Coffee Maker

Figuring out which coffee makers are good and which ones are bad can be pretty tough, which is why we’ve included this buying guide so you know what things you need to check for when buying a coffee maker.

  1. Carafe Versus Single Serve

The first thing you’d want to check is how the coffee is served. If you only plan to be making coffee for yourself, and you don’t see yourself brewing a lot of big batches, then you might be better off getting a simple, single-serve coffee maker.

However, coffee makers with carafes are great for when you need to brew multiple cups of coffee quickly. They don’t retain flavor too well, so make sure to serve the coffee right after brewing. There are also some options out there that store multiple cups of coffee in an internal reservoir. This can keep the flavor of your coffee fresher and make it more convenient to serve. So make sure to consider that when looking at coffee makers.

  1. Brew Time

If you’re buying a coffee maker, chances are, you want things to be fairly quick and easy when it comes to brewing coffee. While most coffee makers keep brewing time to a minimum, there are some models out there that will have you waiting up to 8 minutes before you can have your coffee.

An ideal brew time that doesn’t compromise flavor or take up too much of your schedule is 3-5 minutes. While one of the BrewStations featured on this list can brew a cup in about a minute, others aren’t like that. 

But considering how important time is in the morning, especially if you’re a busy person, it’s important to get a coffee maker with a quick brewing time.

  1. Brewing Options

If you’re very particular about the flavor of your coffee, you’d want to make sure the coffee maker that you’re getting gives you options when it comes to brewing.

A lot of coffee makers out there won’t give you options when brewing, which is fine if you aren’t too particular about the way your coffee tastes. But if you want to have more control over the taste of your coffee, it might be beneficial to get one with multiple options.

That being said, most coffee makers will only give you a choice between a regular and a bold brew. This isn’t the widest variety, but it should be enough to help you get just the right flavor you need in your coffee.

FAQ’s

Is Hamilton Beach A Good Coffee Maker?

Generally, Hamilton Beach is a brand that produces very good coffee makers. However, it will still depend on the model you choose.
Just like every brand, there will be products of great quality and products of lesser quality. That’s why it’s important to research and take a close look at the coffee maker you want to buy. That way, you can truly discern if it fits your needs and meets your personal requirements for a good coffee maker.

What Is The Best Hamilton Beach Coffee Maker?

There is no objective answer to this question because everyone has different tastes when it comes to coffeemakers. However, our pick for the best Hamilton Beach coffee maker is the Brewmaster 49957.
This model is very flexible, easy to use, and produces great coffee. It is also a two way brewer, which gives you the option to make one cup at a time, or multiple cups at a time. This is why it is our favorite model on this list.

How Does The Hamilton Beach Brewstation Work?

Contrary to popular belief, the Hamilton Beach BrewStation works just like any drip coffee maker. It uses the same standard filter, water, and ground coffee that you’d use with any other drip machine, but the only difference is it stores the coffee in an internal reservoir rather than a carafe. 
This results in the flavor of the coffee being retained for longer and you having a fresher taste in every cup.

How Do I Clean My Hamilton Beach Coffee Maker?

To make sure that your coffee maker lasts you years on end, you have to make sure that you maintain it properly. That means cleaning it well after regular use.
To do this, you have to put the empty carafe and filter basket into the coffee maker and close it properly. After that, put a pint of white vinegar into the water reservoir, and turn your coffee maker on for 30 seconds before turning it off. Give the vinegar some time to remove stains and impurities, then turn it on again to finish the brewing cycle.
After that, you have to rinse the reservoir by pouring water into it and beginning a brewing cycle again. Once that is done, your coffee maker will be clean and ready for brewing again.

Why Does My Hamilton Beach Coffee Maker Leak?

A common reason that these coffee makers leak is because there’s a build up in the tank seal. The best solution to this problem is turning your coffee maker upside down over the sink and using tap water to flush it out. If your coffee maker still leaks after this, it may be another problem causing it. If that turns out to be the case, it may be best to call a professional for help.

Conclusion

There is no definite and absolute best coffee maker out there. Everyone has different tastes and needs when it comes to coffee makers. A coffee maker that may work for you might not work for someone else, which is why it’s important to research thoroughly on your options.

But once you find the right coffee maker, you’ll know. It will brew just the right coffee for you, it will brew it in the right amount of time, and it will give you all the options you need. And once that happens, no one else can tell you that you don’t have the right coffee maker for you.

Leave a Comment