Gaggia Anima vs Saeco Incanto: 2 Almost Identical Machines – Which One Is Better?

I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Read more

Confused between Gaggia Anima vs Saeco Incanto? Check out my review to make the final decision. I have tested both machines for a better understanding of how the devices work. And after considering all the similarities and differences, Saeco Incanto has all my attention.

Saeco Incanto can brew espresso that is very delicious and well-balanced with its 15-bar pump pressure and 5 variable espresso strength settings. However, its milk carafe is what impresses me the most. It froths microfoam as if it’s the easiest thing to do, and I don’t have to chime in to adjust anything. The device wins thanks to its more diverse one-touch recipes as well.

The runner-up Gaggia Anima is a simple machine that solely produces espresso-based shots. A traditional manual steam wand provides a simple at-home barista experience. This one is a nice entry-level alternative for novices, although it doesn’t have as many practical features as Anima Prestige.

Gaggia Anima vs Saeco Incanto: Comparison Chart

Image
THE WINNER (#1)
Saeco Incanto Carafe Super Automatic Espresso Machine with AquaClean filter, Stainless Steel, HD8917/48
THE RUNNER-UP (#2)
Gaggia Anima Coffee and Espresso Machine, Includes Steam Wand for Manual Frothing for Lattes and Cappuccinos with Programmable Options
Model
Saeco Incanto
Gaggia Accademia
Dimensions (LxWxH)
8.5 x 16.9 x 13 inches
8.7 x 16.9 x 13.4 inches
Color/ Material
Silver/ Stainless Steel + Plastic
Silver/ Plastic + Metal
Weight/ Power/ Voltage
15.8 Pounds/ 1600W/ 230V
16 Pounds / 1400W / 110V-120V
Water tank capacity
61 oz
61 oz
Bean hopper size
8.8 oz
8.8 oz
Grinder
Ceramic disc grinder
Flat ceramic burr grinder
Adjustable aroma strength
One-touch cappuccino
Auto-rinse
Adjustable coffee strength
5 levels
5 levels
Programmable brewing temperature
3 settings
3 settings
Bar pump
15 bars
15 bars
Heating element
Single boiler
Single boiler
Coffee specialties
6
3
Control panel
LCD Display + Buttons
LCD Display + Buttons
What I Like
Price
Price not available
$649.00
THE WINNER (#1)
Image
Saeco Incanto Carafe Super Automatic Espresso Machine with AquaClean filter, Stainless Steel, HD8917/48
Model
Saeco Incanto
Dimensions (LxWxH)
8.5 x 16.9 x 13 inches
Color/ Material
Silver/ Stainless Steel + Plastic
Weight/ Power/ Voltage
15.8 Pounds/ 1600W/ 230V
Water tank capacity
61 oz
Bean hopper size
8.8 oz
Grinder
Ceramic disc grinder
Adjustable aroma strength
One-touch cappuccino
Auto-rinse
Adjustable coffee strength
5 levels
Programmable brewing temperature
3 settings
Bar pump
15 bars
Heating element
Single boiler
Coffee specialties
6
Control panel
LCD Display + Buttons
What I Like
Price
Price not available
More Info
THE RUNNER-UP (#2)
Image
Gaggia Anima Coffee and Espresso Machine, Includes Steam Wand for Manual Frothing for Lattes and Cappuccinos with Programmable Options
Model
Gaggia Accademia
Dimensions (LxWxH)
8.7 x 16.9 x 13.4 inches
Color/ Material
Silver/ Plastic + Metal
Weight/ Power/ Voltage
16 Pounds / 1400W / 110V-120V
Water tank capacity
61 oz
Bean hopper size
8.8 oz
Grinder
Flat ceramic burr grinder
Adjustable aroma strength
One-touch cappuccino
Auto-rinse
Adjustable coffee strength
5 levels
Programmable brewing temperature
3 settings
Bar pump
15 bars
Heating element
Single boiler
Coffee specialties
3
Control panel
LCD Display + Buttons
What I Like
Price
$649.00
More Info

Last update on 2023-02-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Gaggia Anima vs Saeco Incanto: Differences

Saeco Incanto wins 2-0 and ties twice against Gaggia Anima. However, its milk carafe does a better job of delivering microfoam efficiently. Its one-touch beverages are worth considering as well.

Espresso extraction

Tie

I can create extremely enticing espresso shots with nice crema owing to the 15-bar pump with Gaggia Anima and Saeco Incanto. This improves the mouthfeel of the beverages by making them heavier and velvetier.

The pair allows you to customize your drinks if you like. It provides a variety of coffee strength and aroma options. Additionally, users may modify each recipe’s volume. With the 5 strength levels that the machines offer, you can customize a bold cup to your liking. The intuitive system will memorize the adjustments and dispense the exact amount the next time you select the same recipe.

Saeco Incanto offers 5 espresso strengths
Saeco Incanto offers 5 espresso strengths

Milk system

Winner: Saeco Incanto

This is one major difference between Saeco Incanto and Gaggia Anima. While the Incanto model I’m reviewing is equipped with a milk carafe, which affects the one-touch panel hugely, the Gaggia Anima only comes with a classic Panarello wand. One is entirely automatic. The other is more manual.

There are benefits and disadvantages to both of them. But with the milk foam texture, I’m on team Saeco Incanto. However, I’m more convinced by its frother’s performance. Microfoam isn’t difficult with this device! On the contrary, Gaggia Anima is more gifted at creamy steamed milk, which is slightly too moist for latte macchiato or authentic cappuccino.

One-touch beverages

Winner: Saeco Incanto

Since Saeco Incanto has one-touch latte macchiato and cappuccino while the Gaggia one doesn’t go further than classic espresso and espresso-based drinks, the former will compliment users’ daily brewing experience much more. You can expect to brew these recipes with one touch only with these devices:

  • Saeco Incanto: espresso, espresso lungo, cappuccino, latte macchiato, milk portion, and hot water
  • Gaggia Anima: Espresso, espresso lungo, and hot water
Saeco Incanto has more presets
Saeco Incanto has more presets

Operational stability

Tie

Both have flaws, like any other espresso machine. What’s important is how serious the flaw is. Make your own judgment based on my experience with the pair.

With Saeco Incanto, from brewing to frothing milk, there isn’t any major issue that sways me from enjoying the device’s functionality. But it does leak water when it’s turned off. I notice water in the dreg drawer and the drip tray. Thus it’s necessary to refill the tank more often and clear the compartments more frequently than Gaggia Anima.

As for Gaggia Anima, its empty-water-tank indicator isn’t very precise. Sometimes, it will notify me even when the tank is full. My solution is to lift the tank and place it again in its slot to trigger the alert to turn off.

Gaggia Anima vs Saeco Incanto: Similarities

Gaggia Anima and Saeco Incanto share many similarities, and I will reveal 2 that will concern your future experience with them.

Single boiler heating element

In my opinion, this pair employs a single boiler as their main heating system, which is a tad too basic. But, they do their job well in delivering hot espresso consistently with good preparation. I usually leave the devices on for 2 or 3 minutes so that they have enough time to heat water properly without rushing.

Gaggia Anima has a single boiler
Gaggia Anima has a single boiler

Had these machines been equipped with a Thermoblock or dual boiler, the after-price surely would skyrocket, which isn’t what we are looking for in an affordable espresso machine. There is a trade-off here!

Auto-purge

With the auto-purge feature, these machines keep the system clean before and after each brewing session, ensuring that there is no nasty odor or gunk left that may form mold or bacteria, affecting users’ health. With the milk system, the devices will ask you if you want to rinse it right after finishing frothing. You will have a limited time to select yes, and it’s advisable to do it quickly.

Quick Rundown Of Saeco Incanto

Saeco Incanto Carafe Super Automatic Espresso Machine with AquaClean filter, Stainless Steel, HD8917/48
  • Elegant design, best materials, and high quality workmanship
  • Creamy cappuccino and latte macchiato at the touch of a button thanks to detachable, hygienic milk carafe
  • Professional disc grinder made of 100% ceramic for consistent performance and natural taste
  • Easy maintenance and cleaning thanks to removable brewing unit and automatic cleansing and descaling procedures
  • Large capacities in compact design: 8.8 ounce bean container, 15x waste container; 60.9 ounce

Last update on 2023-02-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pros
  • Full and aromatic coffees
  • Quiet operation during the bean grinding step
  • Hot coffee temperature
  • Elaborate alert system that updates on the device’s real-time condition
  • 4 preset drinks with milk-based recipes
Cons
  • Leaking problem

Quick Rundown Of Gaggia Anima

Sale
Gaggia Anima Coffee and Espresso Machine, Includes Steam Wand for Manual Frothing for Lattes and Cappuccinos with Programmable Options
  • Note: 1)Too coarse a grind, too little coffee, or insufficiently tamping the grounds before brewing can all lead to inadequate pressure for a proper brew. 2)It is important to note that the amount of espresso extracted will vary depending on the grind size and amount and reprogramming may be needed when the size and amount are adjusted
  • MANUAL FROTHING FOR MILK-BASED DRINKS: Pannarello steam wand for frothing milk
  • PROGRAMMABLE: Programmable brewing options for espresso and espresso lungo
  • TEMPERATURE CONTROL: 3 different temperature settings. Min/177.5 °F, Med/182.9 °F, Max/184.5 °F
  • EASY ACCESS TO WATER RESERVOIR AND BEAN HOPPER: Features a removable 60 oz water reservoir that can be accessed on the top left of the machine, and an 8.8 ounce capacity bean hopper with access from the top right of the machine

Last update on 2023-02-05 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Pros
  • Easy to access and maintain for long-term use
  • Slim profile with sturdy base and tall spouts
  • Customizable brewing settings for temperature and strength
  • Relatively quicker warm-up time for espresso/milk
Cons
  • The water level indicator is slightly inaccurate

Product Video

Related Articles to Saeco Incanto

  1. Saeco Incanto vs Saeco Picobaristo: Honest Review With Complete Comparison
  2. Gaggia Anima Prestige vs Saeco Incanto: 2 Akin Models – Which Performs More Smoothly?
  3. Saeco Incanto vs Breville Barista Express: Is Super-automatic Machines Always Better Than Semi-automatics?
  4. Philips 3200 vs Saeco Incanto: The True Winner And How To Detect A Worthwhile Espresso Machine

Related Articles to Gaggia Anima

  1. Gaggia Anima vs Anima Prestige: Is Anima Prestige More Innovative Than The Standard Anima?
  2. Gaggia Brera vs Anima: Which Super Automatic Machine Is Better?
  3. Gaggia Anima vs Philips 3200 Lattego: Which Model Is Perfect For Cappuccino Lovers?
  4. Gaggia Anima vs Breville Barista Express: What Do These Espresso Machines Have To Offer?
  5. Gaggia Anima vs Velasca: Top Differences Between 2 Mid-range Espresso Machines From Gaggia

References:

5/5 - (1 vote)

Leave a Comment