Top 6 Best Mr. Coffee Maker Reviews & Buying Guide In 2020

"I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. Read more"

Mr. Coffee products boast of being some of the best coffee blends you can enjoy at all times.  Since 1970, this coffee blend has ensured that coffee enthusiasts enjoy the best quality coffee products. These products bring about unique satisfaction by offering delicious tastes and flavors for all their coffee products. Our favorite pick for the Best Mr. Coffee Maker is the Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker with a dual water window. This coffee maker features a large capacity that makes it ideal for preparing coffee for the whole family. This appliance has an easy cord storage that eliminates counter clutter.

See also:

  1. Top 10 Best Coffee Maker with Grinder 2020 (Grind and Brew): Reviews & FAQs
  2. Top 5 Best BPA Free Coffee Maker Reviews 2020: Non-Toxic, Durable, & Lightweight

Quick Summary

Best Overall
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker
Best large capacity coffee maker
Mr. Coffee 10 Cup Coffee Maker, Optimal Brew Thermal System
Best for easy and simple brewing
Mr. Coffee 10 Cup Coffee Maker, Optimal Brew Thermal System
Best for versatility
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker, Stainless Steel Base
Best for custom brewing
Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
Best for consistency
Mr. Coffee 31160392 Easy Measure 12 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker, Black
Mr. Coffee 10 Cup Coffee Maker | Optimal Brew Thermal System
Mr. Coffee Simple Brew Coffee Maker|4 Cup Coffee Machine|Drip Coffee Maker, Black
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker, Stainless Steel/Black Base - Includes Water Filtration
Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker Black/Chrome
Mr. Coffee 31160392 Easy Measure 12 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
$28.09
Price not available
$24.99
$114.58
$40.99
$69.65
-
-
Best Overall
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker, Black
$28.09
Best large capacity coffee maker
Mr. Coffee 10 Cup Coffee Maker, Optimal Brew Thermal System
Mr. Coffee 10 Cup Coffee Maker | Optimal Brew Thermal System
Price not available
Best for easy and simple brewing
Mr. Coffee 10 Cup Coffee Maker, Optimal Brew Thermal System
Mr. Coffee Simple Brew Coffee Maker|4 Cup Coffee Machine|Drip Coffee Maker, Black
$24.99
Best for versatility
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker, Stainless Steel Base
Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker, Stainless Steel/Black Base - Includes Water Filtration
$114.58
-
Best for custom brewing
Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker Black/Chrome
$40.99
-
Best for consistency
Mr. Coffee 31160392 Easy Measure 12 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
Mr. Coffee 31160392 Easy Measure 12 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
$69.65

Top 6 Best Mr. Coffee Maker Reviews & Buying Guide In 2020

#1, Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker-Best Overall

Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker, Black
  • On/off indicator light lets you know when your coffee maker is on or off
  • Grab a cup auto pause stops cycle if you need a cup before brewing is finished
  • Dual water window allows visibility as you fill no more overflows
  • Lift and clean filter basket for fast and easy clean up
  • Easy cord storage eliminates counter clutter. Watts: 900

If you are shopping for a coffee maker that you only need to set up, turn on and brew, then you should consider investing in this Mr. Coffee Maker.  This appliance allows you to brew a rich-tasting cup of coffee instantly from the comfort of your kitchen. The coffee maker has an auto pause feature that stops brewing so that you can pour a cup of delicious coffee before the cycle is complete. With a 26 inches long cord, the appliance is convenient to use around the kitchen. What’s more to note about this coffee maker is that it has an easy cord storage that eliminates clutter on the counter.

Dual water window

The dual water window in this Mr. Coffee maker provides you with a clear view of the level of water while refilling to prevent overflowing. This dual window is strong and sturdy so that it is resistant to breaking. Additionally, there is a Lift & Clean filler basket in the coffee maker that is easy to remove for fast and thorough cleanup.

This appliance has a power on/off indicator light that displays the status of the coffee maker when brewing. This allows you to have great control over the brewing process and also enhances the convenience of using the appliance. The power on light acts as a reminder that alerts you to shut off the appliance. With these indicator lights, you do not need to second guess any of your input settings.

Grab-a-cup Auto pause

This feature is designed to enable you have the best control over the brewing process. The Grab-a-cup Auto pause feature makes it possible for you to enjoy your coffee whenever and however you want. With this appliance, you never have to wait for the brewing cycle to complete so that you can enjoy a delicious cup of coffee. After pouring your cup of coffee, you put the carafe back to the coffee maker for the brewing cycle to resume.

This 12- cup coffee maker has a gold-tone filter that sieves all sediments thereby guaranteeing the taste and flavor of the coffee. The appliance is easy to use as it comes with pre-set functions that make it possible for you to brew your coffee with a single button press. Overall, the appliance is durable and sturdy and designed to offer you reliable brewing service throughout its life.

Pros
  • Sturdy and stylish design
  • Highly efficient and functional
  • Features a pause function that allows you pour a cup of coffee midway the brewing process
  • Large brewing capacity
  • Comes with a dual water window
Cons
  • Lacks an auto shutoff feature

#2, Mr. Coffee 10 Cup Coffee Maker, Optimal Brew Thermal System- Best large capacity coffee maker

Mr. Coffee 10 Cup Coffee Maker | Optimal Brew Thermal System
  • Removable water reservoir for easy filling
  • Just Brewed thermal carafe holds temperature and fresh flavor. Watts - 1300
  • Brews up to 20 percent faster (than competitive units tested) at a hotter temperature of up to 205 for richer taste
  • Gold Tone permanent filter eliminates paper filter cost and waste; water filtration helps remove up to 97 percent of chlorine for better tasting coffee
  • Delay Brew feature sets brew time ahead so you can wake up to fresh brewed coffee; Freshness Timer keeps a tab on coffee freshness from the time it's brewed

This Optimal Brew Thermal System coffee maker is specially designed and built for excellent extraction of the fullest flavor from your coffee. The appliance combines a fast brew speed with high temperature (up to 205 degree Celsius) thereby resulting in an exceptionally tasting coffee. The double-walled thermal carafe in the appliance holds the fresh flavor of the coffee for long. This stainless steel carafe keeps your coffee warm for long and hence you do not need to keep warming your coffee every time you wish to enjoy a delicious cup of coffee.

Temperature & time settings

This Mr. Coffee maker is designed to brew coffee at a maximum temperature range of 205 degrees Celsius thereby guaranteeing that it extracts the full flavors of your favorite coffee during the brewing process. The most amazing aspect worth noting about this coffee maker is that while it reaches such high temperatures, it does not burn your coffee. Therefore, the delicious taste and flavor of your coffee is not interfered with. In addition to this, the appliance is quite fast and boasts of up to 20% quicker time compared to other coffee makers in the market.

The coffee maker comes with a removable water reservoir and a filter basket lift out that allows for quick and easy water filling. The filter is easy to clean and is also efficient in removing impurities and sediments so that your coffee has the best taste and flavor. There is a stainless steel thermal carafe in the appliance that keeps your coffee hot.

Gold tone filter

This appliance by Mr. Coffee has a permanent gold tone filter that has an efficiency of up to 97% for filtering chlorine and other impurities that may affect the flavor and taste of your coffee. The best thing about this permanent filter is that it saves you the cost of investing in paper filters. It is worth noting that this gold tone filter is easy to remove and clean.

This coffee maker has a unique delay brew feature that allows you to delay the brewing timing that meets your preferences and suits your convenience. This delay brew feature is similar to a programmable clock feature that allows you to preset your preferred brew time. Additionally, this appliance guarantees that you are able to enjoy a fresh cup of coffee at all times.

Pros
  • Excellent design and durable build
  • Fast and quick brewing time
  • Permanent gold tone filter
  • Has a delay brew filter
  • Thermal carafe holds hot coffee for long
Cons
  • Coffee grounds may stick on the filter thereby interfering with the free flow of coffee

#3, Mr. Coffee Simple Brew Coffee Maker, 4 Cup Coffee Machine- Best for easy and simple brewing

Mr. Coffee Simple Brew Coffee Maker|4 Cup Coffee Machine|Drip Coffee Maker, Black
  • On/off indicator light lets you know when your coffee maker is on or off
  • Grab-A-Cup Auto Pause stops cycle if you need a cup (1 cup = 5 oz) before brewing is finished
  • Dual water window allows visibility as you fill—no more overflows
  • Removable filter basket for quick and easy cleanup
  • Stain-resistant warming plate is easy to clean.Watts: 650

From most mr coffee maker reviews, coffee makers by this brand are specially designed to provide the best performance, reliability and efficiency to their users. True to this, the Mr. Coffee Simple Brew Coffee Maker boasts of having some of the finest features, functions and quality in the market. This coffee maker is designed to help you make a rich-tasting and delicious expertly brewed cup of coffee. Ideally, the coffee maker is designed to help you enjoy your coffee however you want by brewing it according to your preferences and specifications.

Dual water window

If you have always desired to have a coffee maker that lets you monitor the level of water in your coffee maker, then this Mr. Coffee appliance is a great choice for you. This is because this 4-cup coffee maker comes with a dual water window that allows you to have a clear view of the level of water while reviewing. This also helps in preventing overflowing or water spillage.

The filter basket in the coffee maker is removable thereby providing for easy and fast cleanup. Another unique aspect about this coffee maker is seen in the Grab-A-Cup Auto Pause function that stops the brewing cycle at any point before brewing is complete. What is more amazing about this coffee maker is that it comes with a stain and scratch resistant warming plate that is also easy to clean.

On/off indicator

Leaving your coffee maker on for long sessions can lead to the premature damage of the appliance. To prevent such an outcome, this Mr. Coffee Simple Brew Coffee Maker comes with an indicator light that lets you know when the coffee maker is on or off.

The thermal carafe in this coffee maker is made using durable stainless steel. As such, the carafe lasts for long and also keeps your coffee warm for a considerably long duration of time. This innovative carafe provides you with the best coffee brewing experience. With a capacity of up to 4 cups, the thermal carafe makes it possible to prepare coffee for a small family at once.

Pros
  • Superior design and construction
  • Has a dual water window that lets you monitor water level in the carafe
  • Removable filter basket hence easy to clean
  • Has a power on/off light indicator
  • Easy to operate
Cons
  • The brewing capacity is limited to 4 cups

#4, Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker, Stainless Steel Base- Best for versatility

Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker, Stainless Steel/Black Base - Includes Water Filtration
  • VERSATILE BEVERAGE MAKER: Versatile beverage maker for every hot drink lover with convenient programmable features
  • READY WHEN YOU ARE: Delay brew timer sets ahead of time so your coffee is ready when you are
  • FRESHNESS IN EVERY CUP: Freshness timer lets you know how long it's been since it's brewed
  • GRAB AND GO: Grab-A-Cup feature automatically pauses brew cycle when you need a cup before brewing is complete
  • WATER FILTRATION: Includes water filtration system that removes up to 97 percent of chlorine for better tasting coffee

Are you in the market for a 2-in-1 coffee maker? If yes, you should consider buying the Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Programmable Coffee Maker. This coffee maker not only brews your favorite cup of coffee but also a water filtration system. This highly-efficient system ensures that it removes up to 97% of chlorine in water for the best tasting and delicious coffee. Therefore, this mr coffee 12 cup rapid brew coffee maker ensures that you are able to enjoy the purest and sweetest tasting coffee.

Stylish design

This Mr. Coffee Maker appliance is not only efficient with a high performance but also has a stylish design.  It is a compact coffee maker that rhymes perfectly with other appliances and fittings in the kitchen. Its compactness is one of the reasons why people with small kitchen cabinets prefer using this appliance over other coffee makers in the market. Additionally, the coffee maker is packed with remarkable features that make it fun and exciting to use the coffee maker.

This programmable coffee maker is easy and straightforward to use. For starters, the coffee maker has an easy-lift filter basket that allows for easy cleaning. In addition to this, the coffee maker also has a water level indicator that is strategically positioned to the right for easy visibility when refilling water.

Auto shutoff

With this coffee maker, you do not have to worry about leaving the appliance on for extended hours. This is because it comes with an auto shutoff feature that automatically shuts down the coffee maker after two hours of inactivity. This feature is a lifesaver for people who lead busy lives and hence may forget to shut the appliance off. What is more fascinating about this appliance is that it comes with a cord storage unit that enhances the compactness of the appliance.

This appliance with a mr coffee rapid brew system also comes with a delay brew feature. This feature allows you to set when you want the appliance to automatically turn itself on and start brewing coffee. People who love waking up to the sweet aroma of well brewed coffee will find this feature quite reliable and efficient. Like other Mr. Coffee Makers, this model also has a pause and serve feature. As such, you do not have to wait for the brewing cycle to complete before you can enjoy your cup of coffee.

Pros
  • Has an auto-shutoff function
  • Packed with customizable features including Brew Delay
  • Attractive design with a stylish finish
  • Made using high quality stainless steel
  • Comes with a cord storage unit
Cons
  • It takes a considerably long time duration to brew one pot of coffee

#5, Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker- Best for custom brewing

Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker Black/Chrome
  • Delay Brew timer lets you brew ahead of time, so you can wake up to fresh brewed coffee. Cord length: 26 inches
  • Grab A Cup Auto Pause stops cycle if you need a cup before brewing is finished
  • Water window allows visibility as you fill no more overflows. Removable filter basket for quick and easy cleanup
  • Product dimensions (H X W X D): 10.51 x 5.71 x 8.58 inches. Weight:3.30 pounds
  • 1 Hour Shut Off automatically powers coffee maker down so you don't have to

Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker is designed for coffee lovers who look for functionality and style in their coffee makers. Ideally, this model makes brewing coffee to become a breeze and an easy to accomplish task. The programmable features in this coffee maker enhance the convenience and flexibility of using the appliance for rich-tasting coffee. With a 26-inch cord, the appliance is easy and convenient to use in the kitchen or in an office setting.

Delay brew timer

There is nothing more convenient than owning a coffee maker that has a delay brew timer. This is because the feature allows you to set the appliance to brew your coffee at a certain time. If you are the kind of people who like waking up to a delicious cup of coffee, then you will find this feature quite reliable. You can set the appliance to start brewing coffee a few minutes before you wake up or get home in the evening.

Another exclusive feature in this appliance is the Grab-A-Cup Auto Pause feature. Just like its name suggests, this feature allows you to enjoy a cup of coffee midway the brewing cycle. Additionally, this unique coffee maker by Mr. Coffee also has an auto shutoff feature that powers off the appliance automatically after one hour of inactivity.

Mess-free brewing

This coffee maker by Mr. Coffee is designed uniquely to provide you with a hassle-free and mess-free brewing experience. For starters, the appliance has a water window that allows clear visibility when refilling water for brewing. With this window, you never have to worry about spilling water as you can easily monitor its level through the transparent window. The filter basket in this coffee maker is removable thereby providing for easy and quick cleanup.

The all-black design of the coffee maker enhances the beauty and décor of the coffee maker especially as it rhymes and matches perfectly with other kitchen appliances. The stainless steel construction of the appliance is sturdy and solid thereby making this coffee maker quite durable and long lasting.

Pros
  • Easy to use
  • Has a water window that provides for easy refilling
  • Features a stylish and attractive design
  • Highly efficient and reliable performance
  • Mess-free brewing
Cons
  • Limited 5 cup capacity

#6, Mr. Coffee 31160392 Easy Measure 12 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker- Best for consistency

Mr. Coffee 31160392 Easy Measure 12 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
  • Make consistently great-tasting Coffee with the Mr. Coffee easy measure 12-cup programmable Coffee maker, featuring an easy color-coded measuring system for the right amount of Coffee grounds and water, every time
  • The easy measure Coffee maker also improves taste using a 2-step advanced water filtration system to reduce impurities in water, so Coffee tastes better: stage 1 uses activated carbon to reduce up to 97 percentage of chlorine and provide particle filtration, while stage 2 uses ion exchange resin to reduce calcium
  • "Blooming" makes it easy to get the fullest flavor in every cup by automatically presoaking the Coffee grounds for 30 seconds before brewing, releasing carbon dioxide
  • Other great features include a 4-hour freshness indicator so you can avoid stale Coffee, brew now and brew later options for Coffee when you want it, Grab-a-cup auto Pause so you can grab a cup before the brewing finishes, a gold-tone reusable filter, a large brew basket that holds 25 percentage more grounds than comparable Mr. Coffee 12-cup Coffee makers tested, an extra-long 4-hour auto shut-off, and a convenient automatic clean cycle to help maintain quality taste
  • 1 Year limited

Ever enjoyed a cup of coffee brewed using a coffee maker that has a 2-step water filtration system? If no, then you should invest in the Mr. Coffee 31160392 Easy Measure Coffee Maker.  In addition to having tons of programmable features, this coffee maker comes with a color-coded measuring system that allows you to brew the right water and coffee grounds amount for a well-balanced and delicious cup of coffee.

4-hour freshness indicator

The Easy Measure indicator in the coffee maker shows the length of time that the coffee has been in the pot after brewing. This freshness indicator allows you to know how fresh your coffee is so that you are able to enjoy the best tasting cup of coffee at all times. With this indicator, you save yourself the trouble of having to drink stale coffee.  The appliance also has brew now & brew later options that provide you with the freedom of choosing when you want to brew your coffee.

The larger brew basket in this appliance holds up to 25% more grounds compared to other 12 cup coffee makers in the market. Therefore, if you prefer a strong cup of coffee with a rich flavor, this is the ultimate coffee maker to get. The pause and serve feature in the appliance allows you to pour yourself a cup of coffee before a brewing cycle is complete.

Blooming function

Unlike other coffee makers in the market that do not allow you to personalize the flavor of your coffee, this Mr. Coffee Maker lets you extract the fullest flavor of coffee by automatically pre-soaking your coffee grounds for half a minute before brewing. This releases carbon dioxide from the grounds and is made possible by the blooming function in the coffee maker.

This appliance by Mr. Coffee has a convenient automated clean cycle that helps in maintaining the quality of taste and flavor of your coffee. As such, with this coffee maker, you are able to enjoy only the best flavor from your coffee. The auto shutoff feature in the coffee maker automatically shuts down the appliance after 4 hours of inactivity.

Pros
  • Loaded with unique programmable features
  • Features a unique blooming function
  • Has a larger brew basket
  • 4-hour freshness indicator
  • Has a pause and serve feature
Cons
  • Some people find it complex to use

Buying guide

Figuring out the best Mr. Coffee Maker to buy is not always as straightforward as it is widely presumed. Before you identify the right coffee maker to buy, there are several aspects worth considering. Ideally, just like for other appliances, these coffee makers come with different features and functions. Some of the factors worth considering when you are in the market for these appliances are such as:

Quantity

How many people do you want to brew coffee for at once? If you have a large family, then you will need to settle on a coffee maker with a large capacity. Mr. Coffee Maker appliances with a capacity of 10-12 people are the best choice as they allow to brew enough coffee for everyone. However, if you are shopping for a coffee maker for your own coffee consumption, then a model with a 4 cup capacity is a great choice for you.

Cost

The pricing of Mr. Coffee Maker appliances is done differently depending on features, functions, and capacity among other parameters.  When you are checking the cost of a coffee maker, it is recommendable to check both upfront and maintenance costs. This is because a coffee maker may be seemingly affordable to purchase but quite expensive to maintain. The secret to finding the most affordable coffee maker is by comparing its features with the price. Always settle for a coffee maker that will provide you with the best value for your hard-earned cash.

Programmable settings

Are you looking for a Mr. Coffee Maker that you can program and customize to meet your preferences? If yes, then you need to ensure that you only settle on a model that comes with programmable settings. These settings are such as a Delay Brew function, auto shutoff, and a programmable cleaning cycle. Such coffee makers make it fun and exciting to use the appliances while at the same time ensuring you prepare coffee that meets your taste and flavor preferences.

Size

How much available space do you have in your kitchen? Is your kitchen spacious or congested? These are important questions that you should ask yourself when it comes to choosing the best Mr. Coffee Maker. Ideally, you should only settle on a model that will not create any congestion or confusion in the kitchen. If you have limited space in your kitchen, it is advisable that you settle on a compact coffee maker. Such an appliance does not take up too much space in the kitchen. If your kitchen is spacious, then you are at liberty to choose any size of Mr. Coffee Maker appliance.

Ease of operation

According to mr coffee strong brew selector reviews, a coffee maker that is easy to operate is a worthy investment. Such appliances are convenient and also do not end up taking too much of your time when you are fixing yourself a cup of coffee. Avoid complex coffee makers as such coffee makers make it difficult for you to prepare coffee and are quite troublesome.

Frequently asked questions

Are Mr. Coffee Makers good?

Yes. These coffee makers are designed and developed using the best expertise and skills. They are specially built to provide the best performance and reliability throughout their life.

How long should Mr. Coffee Maker last?

Generally, the life of a Mr. Coffee Maker is mostly influenced by the care and attention you accord these appliances. This is because the brand is sturdy and is known to develop only the best quality products. However, with proper maintenance and care, a Mr. Coffee Maker can last for a couple of years before they fall apart or breakdown.

Are Mr. Coffee Maker appliances ideal for commercial use?

Yes. Mr. Coffee Maker appliances are designed for heavy duty brewing and coffee making. As such, they are ideal for use as commercial coffee makers in restaurants and other public settings. In addition to this, you can also use these appliances in an office.

Conclusion

Mr. Coffee Maker appliances are arguably the best coffee makers in the market. These appliances allow you to enjoy the convenience and experience of brewing your coffee in a professional way like it is done in coffee shops. Whichever Mr. Coffee Maker model you settle for, you can be guaranteed that your investment will give you the best returns.

Leave a Comment